Discussions

AI composing music

  • 1
stripecat - 10:09 3 December 2025 #

I added a brand new AI-composed song to my latest tracked music podcast. It was just a one-off thing. I wanted to hear what the demo scene/tracker scene people thought of it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n-QNcNoDlyY

(It's the first song, 22 seconds in from the start)

The comments have been interesting and the song, which is a remix of Bobble Bobble, got no love from the community.

The most insightful comment on our Discord was this:

"The Bubbly podcast episode has an AI song included. While it's good for inspiration, they all suffer from what Baron of Dubstep calls Math Rock - a synopsis where the "algorithms" just put as much variety and mix everything into a soup that has no sense or rhythm nor has it repeating patterns or recognizable chorus segments. The song may mimic the original, but the "overlay added layer of let's see how much craporama techniques can be packed over the course of the song" is extremely discerning. And I agree, that Bubble Bobble "remix" is exactly an example of this."

Higgie - 16:55 5 December 2025 #

Thanks for notifying! :) I blocked the channel. ;) FCK AI!
Cheers!

stripecat - 09:12 7 December 2025 #

Wow. That was not what I expected. I didn't link to the channel creating those tunes. I linked to my podcast that just this once played an AI tune. :) So you blocked out a chnanel that don't even play AI tunes. But I guess I stepped right into that one :)

  • 1

Log in to reply.